Latest Ukraine Analysis: Crimea Culpa! Why the United States and Russia Stand to Lose from Ukraine Crisis

Screen Shot 2014-03-04 at 13.42.47The ongoing crisis in Ukraine threatens at best years of regional instability and at worst Europe’s bloodiest war in two decades, but there are broader geostrategic casualties, too. While news media across much of the world are rehashing clichés regarding the possibility of a mid-twentieth century-style ‘cold war’, we at Mediolana believe that the Really Important Insight emerging from this crisis is the fragility of the two largest directly interested parties: the United States and Russia.

United States

  1. The US risks being exposed once again as a rapidly fading hyperpower. Its response to the crisis has been limited to threatening sanctions against Russia for its intervention in Crimea – but it is standing on shaky ground.
  2. The most recent Iraq War is proving problematic insofar as its legality is at best highly contentious. It involved the invasion of an internationally-recognised sovereign state that had not attacked the United States; the world being aware of both this and its dire outcome places the US in a position of questionable legitimacy.
  3. Economically the United States is in no position to pursue another military campaign, and is unlikely to be for the foreseeable future. Again, its much-publicised battles with its own debt ceiling have done little to instil confidence in its ability to pursue complex and costly international interventions.

Russia

  1. Prima facie, Russia could stand to gain territorially and in terms of regional influence from the Crimea Crisis: at the very least, one would expect the emergence of a highly autonomous Crimean region federated – de facto if not de jure – to what is already the largest country in the world by land mass.
  2. However, in the context of the 2014 Ukrainian Revolution, Russia’s possible seizure of Crimea looks at best opportunistic and at worst bordering on the desperate. It is a show of military force and power at a time when the Ukrainian street has proven that it is capable of effecting political change – and could perhaps have echoes in Moscow.
  3. While the average Muscovite is considerably better off in many respects than their counterpart in Kiev, the Russian Federation remains a country that according to all respected international indices is corrupt and poorly-administered. It is also a country where information technology is spreading with speed – and as the Swedish author, speaker and economist Kjell A. Nordström has noted, authoritarian governments rely in part on controlling information, something that is almost certainly going to be increasingly difficult to do worldwide.

Screen Shot 2014-03-04 at 13.44.14

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Political Science, Politics

2 responses to “Latest Ukraine Analysis: Crimea Culpa! Why the United States and Russia Stand to Lose from Ukraine Crisis

  1. Putin has yet to learn the meaning of ‘soft power’. Imposing control is going to be less and less possible in today’s globalised hyperconnected world. This ‘cold war’ warrior is never going to understand that. Having a huge military allows one to indulge in one’s self-deceptions, but he is incapable of seeing what is best for Russia. If Russia does want to have influence in countries on its borders it’s going have to earn it by being ‘liked’ by them. That’s much harder than using force.

    • You are quite right to point to the importance of soft power, a vitally important concept that is all too often forgotten these days, despite the obvious expense and pitfalls of armed intervention. Russia has a wealth of cultural treasures – but can it make the most of them?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s